About Menu Experience Gallery Reviews Contact Call Now
Herkimer's Kitchen

Every meal at Theolevi feels like coming home to something wonderful

Nestled on S Washington St, we serve heartfelt dishes made with care — where warm hospitality meets flavors that linger in your memory long after the last bite.

Reserve a Table Explore the Menu
Popular Signature burger on a plate
Our Signature Burger
Hand-formed, locally sourced, and cooked to perfection
Freshly brewed coffee
10+
Years Serving Herkimer
Family dining together
5,000+
Happy Diners Each Year
Chef preparing a dish
Chef-Driven Comfort Food
Every plate tells a story — crafted with passion, served with a smile, and made to bring people together at the table.
Our Story
A place where
good food meets genuine warmth
Warm restaurant interior with wooden tables
Made with Love Since Day One

Rooted in Herkimer, built on hospitality

Theolevi was born from a simple belief: the best meals are the ones shared in a space where you feel truly welcome. Located on 118 S Washington St, we've become a neighborhood staple — the kind of restaurant where regulars know the staff by name and every visit feels like a reunion.

Our kitchen draws on time-honored recipes and the freshest local ingredients to create dishes that taste like comfort, every single time. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for a leisurely dinner, we want you to leave feeling satisfied — inside and out.

Fresh, local ingredients
Family-friendly atmosphere
Catering available
Walk-ins always welcome
The Experience
More than a meal —
a moment to savor
From the moment you walk through our door, everything is designed to make you feel at ease.

Fresh Ingredients

We source locally whenever possible, ensuring every ingredient brings peak flavor to your plate.

Warm Hospitality

Our team treats every guest like family — because that's exactly how you'll feel when you dine with us.

Cozy Atmosphere

Soft lighting, comfortable seating, and a buzz of conversation — the perfect backdrop for any occasion.

Private Events

Host your next gathering with us — we'll handle the food so you can focus on the celebration.

Kind Words
What our guests say
The best reward is hearing from the people who make our restaurant special.

"We stumbled upon Theolevi on a whim and ended up staying for hours. The food was incredible, but it was the warmth of the staff that really made it special. We'll definitely be back!"

M
Michelle R.
Herkimer, NY

"Theolevi is our go-to spot for family dinners. The kids love the burgers, my wife swears by the pasta, and I can't get enough of the steak. It's become our tradition."

D
David T.
Herkimer, NY

"Hosted a small birthday dinner here and everything was flawless. The team was attentive without being intrusive, and the food kept coming — every dish better than the last."

S
Sarah L.
Herkimer, NY

Ready to taste the difference?

Walk in, call ahead, or reserve your table — we can't wait to welcome you to Theolevi.

(315) 866-2858 Send a Message
Get in Touch
We'd love to hear from you

Visit us or reach out

Address 118 S Washington St
Herkimer, NY 13350
Phone (315) 866-2858
Email hallenbeck1@msn.com
Hours Mon – Thu: 11am – 9pm
Fri – Sat: 11am – 10pm
Sunday: 12pm – 8pm

Send us a message

✓ Thank you! Your message has been received — we'll get back to you shortly.
Is this your business?This is my business